If you are a follower of wwi history, this fictional story about an actual event is worth while. In 2005, french filmmaker christian carion released his second fulllength feature film. I know that various specific elements are at least loosely based on reallife events e. On christmas eve 1914, the warring soldiers fighting in the front. Based on the true story of three armies in the bloody trenches of world war i and the miraculous christmas eve truce they unexpectedly forge. Mar 03, 2006 joyeux noel, a glossy french antiwar movie with melted snowflakes in its eyes, tells the true story of an improvised christmas truce during the first year of world war i.
Throughout the film, we follow the german, french, and scottish soldiers as they learn to set aside their differences, put themselves in each others shoes, and manage to have a cease fire on christmas. French film joyeux noel merry christmas is based on a real incident during. The story behind the film is of the 1914 christmas truce, an event that took place as world war i was just getting started, and almost ended it before it began. Nikolaus sprink, exceptional tenor at the berlin opera house, will have to. Christian carions joyeux noel for its depiction of the littleknown but true fraternization story of the 1914 christmas eve truce declared by germans, french, and scottish infantrymen near lens, france. Joyeux noel, which translated to english means merry christmas, was. Dec 02, 2005 the astonishing war story that a nation chose to forget. The film is based on a true story, but the characters and specific plot points are fictional. You feel like youre mostly watching different types of people instead of getting to know anyone real. The movie s weakness comes late in the proceedings. Still, joyeux noel is a well made movie with a stellar international cast.
Joyeux noel is an exceptional film that tells the true story of the spontaneous 1914 christmas truce of world war i. Viewers will have at the back of their minds that the story is based on real events that occurred in the trenches of world war i, christmas 1914. That film, joyeux noel merry christmas, a panoramic portrait of soldiers from three countries who participated in one of these occasions, set. Joyeux noel is based on true accounts of the opposing armies in 1914 during world war i coming together, in peace, to celebrate christmas. Dec, 2017 the movie joyeux noel tells the inspirational story of the christmas truce. Christian carion on joyeux noel merry christmas this movie is inspired by a true story, which occurred in the trenches of the world war i battlefield on christmas eve in 1914. The story concludes 20 minutes before the movie ends. The troops from england were actually scottish, with bagpipes. So, some years back, i remember watching an absolutely wonderful film called joyeux noel, which is apparently based on actual events during world war i namely, the christmas truce of 1914. But its the only problem he seems to be aware of, and this is the death sentence for joyeux noel. Joyeux noel has its share of bloodshed, especially in a deadly early charge, but the movie is about a respite from carnage, and it lacks the brutal details of films like paths of glory, a very long engagement and, from later wars, saving private ryan and platoon. French film revisits the true story of christmas eve 1914 when.
Although the truce was not a generalized event, it did happen in quite a few areas all along the front line. I wanted to show this in joyeux noel and filmed the cruel execution scene. This momentous event on the batterfield changed the lives of the soldiers from france, germany and england. Film research analysis the film joyeux noel is the true story of the christmas truce of december 1914 in the trenches of world war 1. One engagement of the great war wwi involved some 3,000 soldiers from the scottish, french, and german armies. The astonishing war story that a nation chose to forget. The films concept that combines singing christmas carols with world war 1 is a strange one, but it is handled masterfully. This very touching story about a true occurrence during the first christmas of the great war is very moving. A christmas truce forged by germans, french and scots the new. Academy awardr, golden glober and bafta nominee for best foreign film, joyeux noel merry christmas tells the truelife story of the spontaneous christmas eve truce declared by scottish, french and german troops in the trenches of world war i.
It was the only moment of sanity in an otherwise gruesome experience in futility. In reality, the tom cat was accused of spying and was arrested by the french army and then shot according to regulations. Carions wellmeaning film tells the strangebut true story of the christmas truce. This was the case with the story of the cat who roamed from one trench to the other and in the film ended up being imprisoned. The commanders decided to have a truce to have the holiday together. Everything you need to know about joyeux noel movie 2006. Joyeux noel or merry christmas should be shown every year on television. This movie is based on a true story, during world war 1.
It was written and directed by christian carion, and screened out of competition at the 2005 cannes film festival the film, which includes one of the last appearances of ian richardson before his death, was. For the first thirty minutes or so i was wondering what had i gotten myself into by watching this movie. I imagine anyone who sees this film will make an emotional connection to it regardless of their race, color, or creed. A christmas truce forged by germans, french and scots. On christmas eve of 1914, at several places along the front lines, soldiers on opposing sides declared their own ceasefires for the night and celebrated christmas with their enemies. It happens in the trenches during christmas of 1914. Charting the converging experiences of british, french and german soldiers in december 1914, joyeux noel is a moving portrayal of an incredible true story and a bold testament to the idea of universal humanity that these events have now come to symbolise.
The movie stars benno furmann as private nikolaus sprink, a german tenor who also sings opera with his beloved wife, anna sorenson diane kruger who becomes concerned when he goes off to war. In fact, news of the actual truce went unreported for more than a week. The astonishing war story that a nation chose to forget telegraph. Based on a true story, the film chronicles the start of what was then known as the great war, but what we know today as world war i. It is beautiful movie about the true meaning of christmas. When war breaks out in the lull of summer 1914, it surprises and pulls millions of men in its wake. Joyeux noel from based on a true story on radiopublic. The truth is murky on this because trucesrather than a single truceexisted up and down the lines. Based on a true story, the film dramatizes a peculiar ceasefire on christmas eve 1914, when battletested germans and their scottish and. Film research analysis of joyeux noel 779 words bartleby. Joyeux noel on dvd november 14, 2006 starring diane kruger, benno furmann, guillaume canet, gary lewis.
Joyeux noel, a glossy french antiwar movie with melted snowflakes in its eyes, tells the true story of an improvised christmas truce during the. Ian richardson shows up as an anglican bishop whose purpose is to give a sermon that hammers points carion has previously made in a more eloquent and subtle fashion. He endeavored to stay true to the real stories, but one of the things he had to change was the fate of the cat that crossed into various trenches. Christmas arrives, with its snow and multitude of family and army. French film revisits the true story of christmas eve 1914 when soldiers fighting in world war i put down their weapons. The war film, joyeux noel, directed by christian carion in 2006, tells the true story of the soldiers that faced this moral dilemma, laying down their weapons for a 24hour truce over christmas. Seemingly out of nowhere, enemy soldiers decided to lay down their arms and instead spent december 25th, 1914, by singing christmas songs and exchanging gifts. But its director, christian carion, claims the film is historically accurate. That film, joyeux noel merry christmas, a panoramic portrait of soldiers from three countries who participated in one of these. The story clearly and gracefully brings out the true meaning of christmas, especially in the two christmas carols sung in german, and the powerfully reverent catholic. The story behind the film is of the 1914 christmas truce, an event that. The director does a brilliant job in depicting three military units like the germans, french, and the scottish who are fighting the first christmas away from their loved ones and facing an invisible enemy.
Academy award, golden globe and bafta nominee for best foreign film, joyeux noel merry christmas tells the truelife story of the spontaneous christmas eve truce declared by scottish, french and german troops in the trenches of world war i. Merry christmas or joyeux noel is a fantastic antiwar movie. With the christmas season upon us, i wanted to cover a film thatd help represent the christmas spirit. Joyeux noel merry christmas is a 2005 epic war drama film based on the christmas truce of december 1914, depicted through the eyes of french, scottish, and german soldiers. The soldiers had been living in the trenches, engaged in combat on the frontline only hours before, when through a unique set of circumstances, their. A christmas truce forged by germans, french and scots the. The trailer of the film describes a a true story that history has been forgotten. Enemies leave their weapons behind for one night as they band together in brotherhood and forget about the brutalities of war. The movie joyeux noel tells the inspirational story of the christmas. Rentals include 30 days to start watching this video and 48.
Joyeux noel celebrates brief holiday truce in wwi it seems the wrong time of year to release a movie called merry christmas. Though the movie is slow at times because it is shot in a straightforward, sometimes stodgy, way, it becomes incredibly compelling as the story unfolds. The film holds such current significance in francogerman relations that it was showcased at the. There is very little else out there about this almost forgotten world war. With diane kruger, benno furmann, guillaume canet, natalie dessay.
Joyeux noel or merry christmas in french tells the true story of a brief ceasefire among french, scottish and german troops on christmas eve 1914, in the thick of the great war. Joyeux noel, a glossy french antiwar movie with melted snowflakes in its eyes, tells the true story of an improvised christmas truce during the first year of world war i. Joyeux noel and remembering the christmas truce of 1914. In its own way it is captivating in spite of its faults. Antiwar joyeux noel reenacts wwi christmas truce tallahassee. During world war i, enemy soldiers up and down the trenches put aside their weapons and chose peace. The truth is murky on this because trucesrather than a. Noels main problem is a script that too often takes the easy way out of a situation, and doesnt develop characters in a meaningful way. It was written and directed by christian carion, 2 and screened out of competition at the 2005 cannes film festival. Based on a true story, the film recreates one christmas night during wwi when enemies were able to lay aside their differences, visit each o. Nov 26, 2014 joyeux noel takes a break from the war. Noel s main problem is a script that too often takes the easy way out of a situation, and doesnt develop characters in a meaningful way.
Academy awardr, golden glober and bafta nominee for best foreign film, joyeux noel merry christmas tells the true life story of the spontaneous christmas eve truce declared by scottish, french and german troops in the trenches of world war i. Nov, 2019 based on a true story podcast 8,431 views. Dec 21, 2018 joyeux noel is a french film based on the true story of the christmas truce of 1914, when soldiers from opposing sides who put their differences aside and left their trenches to engage in a ceasefire for christmas. On christmas eve, the german side began to sing silent night. The oscarnominated french film joyeux noel merry christmas is based on a real incident during the early days of world war i. The five leads the three lieutenants, who are only too happy to have peace break out in their tiny section of the front, and singers nikolaus and anna who are the fairy story catalyst for the spontaneous celebration are all fully drawn by the script, by helmer carion, and by the actors who. Dec 21, 2011 joyeux noel, french for merry christmas, is the story about a group of soldiers scots, french, and germans who laid down their arms and joined each other in peace during christmas, if only for a few days. Its sentimentality is muted by the thought that this moment of. Joyeux noel, french for merry christmas, is the story about a group of soldiers scots, french, and germans who laid down their arms and joined each other in peace during christmas, if only for a few days. In december 1914, an unofficial christmas truce on the western front allows soldiers from opposing sides of the first world war to gain insight into each others way of life. Dec 08, 2017 joyeux noel retells the story of a welldocumented event that occurred on a battlefield in france on christmas eve, 1914. Carions wellmeaning film tells the strangebuttrue story of the christmas truce. Joyeux noel, or merry christmas is a poignant, emotionally stirring, sometimes too sentimental movie that is perfect for the holiday season.
I bought joyeux noel because there is not much media out there for the wwi period. The film does an exquisite job at bringing the characters to life, and at. The final portion of joyeux noel is rambling and longwinded. Joyeux noel was a nice though not great subtitled movie. Joyeux noel is a compressed, fictionalized version of events that took place along the western front as well as in turkey at christmas, 1914, easter, 1915 and to a lesser extent at christmas that. At the end of joyeux noel, theres a bit of text on the screen that says the characters are fictional. Joyeux noel merry christmas is a 2005 epic war drama film based on the christmas truce of. The truly remarkable thing about this story is that, despite how hokey it may sound to some, its all pretty much entirely true.
563 306 1093 776 559 1094 852 1264 592 316 629 208 613 467 1560 1133 255 198 969 91 1168 1016 1553 1512 405 554 1140 48 161 1024 836 1134 1128 1470 687 781 845 1341 1175 1094 25 386 1442 938 1033 1036 1451